The Psyché  1876; "The Cheval Glass" by Berthe Morisot

The Psyché
1876; “The Cheval Glass”
by Berthe Morisot

During my first year of teaching at the University of Cincinnati, the father of one of my students appeared at my office door one day. It was Ash Wednesday and he wore the requisite symbol of the occasion on his forehead. Initially, I was unsure why he had come, but once he began to talk I realized that he simply wanted me to know that his son had not always been the young man whose emotional outbursts and tendency to wander in and out of the classroom had disrupted and frustrated me for most of the term. Though I was prohibited by law from discussing the son’s behavior and progress with the father, I felt the intensity of his grief, so I did what any of us would: I let him talk to me. According to this father’s narrative, the confused and angry young man I knew bore no resemblance to the joyful and intelligent child he had once been—a child whose life seemed charmed and full of promise. As the grief-stricken father talked, he revealed that earlier that year his son had been diagnosed with schizophrenia; he also described the family’s harrowing battle to find help for his son in this country’s often insensitive and ineffectual mental health system. He told me that his marriage had disintegrated under the weight of that struggle. That was all he said. For the next few minutes I served as the accidental witness to his mournful weeping. I never again saw the father or his son, but I have thought often of them both, the streak of ashes on the father’s forehead a testament to the grief he felt over the loss of his son to an illness that insists on constantly making its presence known, that every day steals a little part of the lives it touches.

Twenty years later, I look back and I understand from painful experience what it’s like to have your core life plans completely obliterated by a life change you could never have imagined. For that father, it was his son’s schizophrenia; for me, it was MS. When I was diagnosed at about this time of the year in 2008 I was initially convinced that my disease would not progress, that I would certainly be one of those people whose MS would be “benign.” By the time I finished my sabbatical in 2010 it was clear that I would not be able to return to work. For a long time – years – I was convinced that my productive life was over, that I had no way of leaving any kind of “mark” on the world. As I have begun to think about it, though, I have realized that there’s really no such thing as leaving a mark on the world – at least not in the way most people think about it. The only thing of any importance that we leave are the memories that resurface in our loved ones’ consciousness from time to time. In other words, what we leave is love. Of course, that sounds pretty sappy, especially for someone like me who tends to dislike the sappy. That said, it’s really true.

We will have done everything right if someone we loved looks at the colorful fall leaves we enjoyed so much and thinks of us, if someone passes a house we once lived in and thinks of the good times they had with us there, or someone remembers with great pleasure any time they spent with us. Those tender feelings we leave with the people we care about are our only necessary legacy. We need not worry about leaving anything else behind because nothing else matters. I have a set of Word computer documents that are starting paragraphs for blog posts. One of them that I wrote recently is focused on the sadness I feel when I think about everyone else going off to school at the beginning of the school year. That must’ve been written less than a year ago. Honestly, with everything that’s happened I don’t remember writing that paragraph, but when I look at it now I find that I don’t feel that way any longer. I am happy with the life I have built at home. The time I spend resting and otherwise taking care of myself makes it possible for me to interact with my children, grandchildren, and other people I love. In other words, I am able to live a life because I accept (maybe even embrace) the limitations this disease imposes on my life.

It has been 20 years since I have seen either that Ash Wednesday father or his son. I hope that those two decades have been kind to both those men. I hope that the father has found some peace in his relationship with his son; I hope that the son has been able to find a treatment that offers as much relief from his disease as possible. As I’ve said in recent posts, I am in the process of returning to myself, of regaining a sense of emotional stability. Sometimes I remember some of the complicated feelings I felt during the year or so when I was having so much trouble with my medications and I become aware of how much emotional pain I was in. It’s hard for me to believe that the person who inhabited my body during that time is the same person who inhabits it now. People keep telling me that I am “back.” I feel that and I hear it in my voice and I see it in the way people respond to me. I value that and it feels wonderful to be back in the world with friends and family. Despite that, a part of me understands that even that other self—the one my partner, close friends, and I have come to call the “batshit-crazy” self is a part of me, that she exists somewhere deep inside my psyche and might reappear if circumstances dictate. Of course, my hope is that the circumstances will never be right for such a thing to happen, but I feel her as a real part of me. The idea of leaving her behind brings both relief and grief – relief because I never want her to be in control of my life again; grief because she represents a childhood I overcame in order to get to this stable place in my life. She is a painfully wonderful symbol of that which hurt me the most, but which I survived. To banish her from my life entirely would be too great a loss, so I keep her here close to me and hope that she resides quietly deep inside that emotional spot we all keep to ourselves.

5 thoughts on “What We Leave Behind
  1. Lovely piece. It reminds me a little bit of Solzhenitsyn’s quote: “If only there were evil people somewhere insidiously committing evil deeds, and it were necessary only to separate them from the rest of us and destroy them. But the line dividing good and evil cuts through the heart of every human-being. And who is willing to destroy a piece of his own heart?” The “bat-shit crazy” part of oneself isn’t evil, but we all have those raw-material parts of ourselves that were what we had to use when we were building our character. I’m grateful for the reminder that we need to be a little bit protective, even of those parts that we’d prefer not to see again. Thank you.

  2. I will always treasure the time I get to hang out with you—batshit crazy or not. I am glad you have “returned,” but I love all of you. If Ms. Batshit Crazy rears her head I’ll still want to see you.

  3. Phew, Madame de la Batshit what a scorcher. You are indeed truly back and expressing yourself with a new power that could only have been gained from experiencing the dark side. From struggle comes art.
    XX Jane

  4. Perfect as always. You have touched my heart, and others as well I’m sure, and I thank you for that. That is your legacy.

  5. I just wanted to take a moment to say how much this touched me on multiple levels. First, I have had that defining moment. For me, it was when my mother announced that she was dying of cancer. That day quite literally changed the course of my life. Second, you are so right that making a big impact on the world is not so much what matters in life. My mother was a suburban housewife. That doesn’t sound like much, but she touched thousands of people who, still, more than a decade after she passed, compare themselves to her. There is not a day that does not pass that I don’t still recall what an amazing person she was, and I still use her as a measure of myself. I will never be what she was. But at least I have a map of what a good person ought to be, and for that I am very thankful. Not everyone gets that gift in life. Third, I value my mind more than anything else about myself. I’ve often thought that I could deal with any diagnosis, crisis, etc. in which I lost virtually any of myself but my brain. You have established that this is true. Sure, you have a physical ailment. But you also have a brain, and you keep going, which is very significant even in the minds of those who don’t personally know you.

I Love Your Comments! I hope you'll keep them coming!

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s